Aldi loses court battle against Charlotte Tilbury over “lookalike” makeup

30187
Aldi Charlotte Tilbury court battle copyright
Charlotte Tilbury first bought legal action over a breach of copyright against Aldi in December
// Aldi lost High Court battle against Charlotte Tilbury over “lookalike” makeup range
// Charlotte Tilbury first brought legal action over a breach of copyright against the German discounter back in December
// Aldi denied all accusations at the time

Aldi has lost a High Court battle with eponymous cosmetics retailer Charlotte Tilbury over a “lookalike” makeup line.

The judge described the similarities between the two as “substantial”.

Makeup artist Charlotte Tilbury first brought legal action over a breach of copyright against the German discounter back in December, all of which Aldi denied at the time.

However, the High Court found that the packaging of Aldi’s Lacura Broadway Shape and Glow, which retailed at £6.99, had striking similarities to Tilbury’s Filmstar Bronze and Glow palette, which sells for £49.

Aldi estimated to have sold around 20,000 units of the bronzers before the action was bought, while Tilbury’s Filmstar Bronze and Glow palette has generated sales of nearly £13 million for the brand since it first started selling in 2013.

“Islestarr allege Aldi saw the success of the Filmstar palette and decided to copy features, so as to produce its own versions,” Judge John Linwood said.

“Islestarr say it demonstrates Aldi’s ethos of selling lookalike versions of well-known brands cheaply to encourage footfall in their stores”.

An Aldi spokesman said: “This matter relates to a product that was on sale for a very short period around December 2018. The dispute has since been fully resolved.”

The size of the damages awarded to Tilbury has not been revealed.

Click here to sign up to Retail Gazette’s free daily email newsletter

5 COMMENTS

  1. It would depend on the ingredients in my opinion.
    If they are the same then it’s right, but I doubt the ingredients are the same therefore wrong for court action. Very happy that Aldi continues to give its customers excellent value for money.

  2. Aldi sells lowest quality food and lowest quality of organic foods. It is affordable, but you are not getting a deal because you still get what you pay for. low quality for lower price. And the general customers at Aldi look miserable.

  3. Not fair! There are many lookalike dupes and the public should decide how much they want to spend. It just shows how much profit she must be making. Try W7 bronze and glow pallette which is much cheaper and just as good. I will never buy Charlotte Tilbury stuff again since finding out that her £49 moisturiser was no better than Nivea

Leave a Reply to Sandra Cancel reply

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here