John Lewis closure in Sheffield is “hammer blow” for local retail, MP says

John Lewis closure in Sheffield is
The John Lewis branch in Sheffield, England.
// Decision to close the John Lewis store in Sheffield described as a “hammer blow” for the city
// Sheffield City Council is in the middle of a £480m regeneration project, of which the John Lewis site is a part
// John Lewis has been in Sheffield since the 1940s, when it took over the Cole Brothers department store

The decision to close the John Lewis store in the centre of Sheffield, which was at the heart of a £480 million regeneration project, has been described as a “hammer blow”.

It is only six months since Sheffield City Council agreed a multimillion-pound deal with the department store company to restructure the lease of the landmark 1960s Cole Brothers building, opposite City Hall and the war memorial.

The deal, which included plans for a major refurbishment of the Barker’s Pool store, was struck after the site was confirmed as a lynchpin of the Heart of the City II scheme – an ongoing £480 million investment in a fundamental regeneration of Sheffield city centre.


Yesterday, the John Lewis Partnership announced plans to not reopen eight John Lewis stores when lockdown on non-essential retail is lifted from next month, a move that would affect almost 1500 staff.

The site at Sheffield, which employs around 300 people, was one of the eight stores earmarked for closure.

It is also just a few hundred metres from the Debenhams building, which is also closing down after the retailer went into liquidation in December.

Following the decision, Sheffield Heeley Labour MP Louise Haigh said on Facebook: “This will be a hammer blow for Sheffield and leave a gaping hole in our city centre.

“John Lewis is a huge draw, and the closure will have a knock-on effect for businesses across Sheffield.

“We can’t continue with a situation where five US tech firms account for £1.3 billion in lost corporation tax every year, while high street shops pay business rates under a system that hasn’t been reformed for years.

“The government are washing their hands of any responsibility for reviving our high streets, and creating a level playing field for local businesses. It’s the communities and workers who rely on them that are paying the price.”

At the time of the agreement over the lease in August last year, Mazher Iqbal, cabinet member for business and investment at Sheffield City Council, said: “Securing John Lewis in the city centre has been one of our key long-term ambitions, so we’re delighted to get a deal done – particularly during a difficult time for the high street on a national scale.”

Yesterday, Sheffield Council city centre development director Nalin Seneviratne said: “The planned closure of John Lewis is sad news.

“As Cole Brothers in 1847, then as John Lewis, it has been a retail landmark in our city for decades.

“We also need to think about those staff who, after an already challenging year, now face more uncertainty. We will work to provide as much support as we can to those who may be impacted.

“It’s no secret that high streets across the country have faced challenges over the past decade, and no-one could have prepared for the impacts of the global pandemic.

“But Sheffield is a resilient city, and we already have in place ambitious plans for a city centre that competes on a global stage.

“Our Heart of the City plans will deliver between 5500 and 7000 jobs, create social spaces, homes, showcase our incredible culture, deliver restaurants, workspace, creative hubs – with a focus on socialising, alongside a fantastic retail offering that supports new and existing businesses.

“There is a lot to look forward to in Sheffield and we’re already seeing great progress, with West Bar’s leisure and office spaces, Cambridge Street Collective’s cultural and entertainment hub, multimillion-pound investment in the Moor and Fargate, and proposals for the 6000ft Pounds Park, with a cafe, bar, terrace, water play area and urban orchard.

“We are already working towards building a world-class, sustainable, modern city centre that drives our economy and can continue to thrive long into the future.”

Sheffield Council said there would be no direct financial loss to the local authority which still owns the building and the site.

A spokeswoman said the deal last year saw the council pay £3 million to John Lewis for the surrender of the existing lease, which had a term of 42 years remaining at a nominal ground rent.

It then entered into a new 20-year modern lease for the building in return for a turnover-based rent.

She said that John Lewis was still tied to the lease agreement and a payment would be due to bring that to an end.

“Losing John Lewis in Sheffield deals another blow to retail workers who are among those who have been hit hardest by the pandemic,” Sheffield City Region Mayor Dan Jarvis said.

“My heart goes out to the workers and their families whose livelihoods are at risk.

“The store has been a cornerstone of the city’s retail offer for more than a century. I am working with John Lewis and Sheffield City Council to determine what this means for those whose jobs are now on the line and what can be done to support them.”

Jarvis said an £860 million stimulus package had been agreed earlier this week to start the recovery of South Yorkshire’s economy, which includes £300 million to “transform our places and high streets”.

Many people in Sheffield still refer to the huge store as Cole Brothers – a reference to the department store which dated back to the 1840s and was taken over by John Lewis in the 1940s.

The store moved to its current purpose-built site in 1963 and John Lewis dropped the Cole Brothers branding in 2002.

with PA Wires

Click here to sign up to Retail Gazette‘s free daily email newsletter


  1. She should be fired in my view the Chair as the current SEM team haven’t a clue to run a large retailer. How anyone can waste money on a large store in Birmingham only to shut it when it’s the second largest city and soon will have no department store once H of F gets kicked out of their store is ridiculous. Same with Aberdeen where people won’t travel 240 m round trip to Edinburgh or 3 hours on the train and the same in Ashford and TW. Those stores were busy and packed. It’s short termism. £21m wasted on Peterborough only to shut it.

    Good luck forcing people online as I don’t do it because had faulty goods then a hassle to take them back to a store. Not doing it. Not paying for returns. Get a new Chair who knows physical retail. Many of these places now have no department store and don’t buy the model is dead or unsustainable. They have a captive market in these locations.

  2. Probably Sheffield city centre would do better if the council hadn’t approved the building of the Meadowhall mall…. one city can’t support two retail centres


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here