Sony has defeated a nearly £2bn class action lawsuit accusing it of overcharging millions of UK PlayStation customers for digital games and add-on content.
London’s Competition Appeal Tribunal dismissed the case in its entirety on Tuesday, ruling that the claimants had failed to establish that the retailer had breached competition law.
The lawsuit, brought by consumer campaigner Alex Neill on behalf of around 12.2 million UK PlayStation users, alleged that Sony had abused its dominant market position by requiring digital games and additional content to be purchased exclusively through its PlayStation Store.
It claimed the restrictions prevented rival digital retailers from competing on the platform, allowing Sony to charge consumers excessive prices.
Lawyers representing the claimants argued that PlayStation customers had paid around 20 per cent more for digital content than they would have in a competitive market, seeking almost £2bn in compensation.
However, the tribunal rejected the allegations following a trial that ran from March to May this year.
The judges found that the claimants had failed to demonstrate Sony held a dominant position in the relevant market, pointing to competition from rival gaming platforms and physical game sales.
The tribunal also ruled that the evidence did not establish that Sony’s profit margins on digital games were excessive or unfair.
Sony defended its business model throughout the proceedings, arguing that it had invested billions in developing an integrated gaming platform that benefited consumers.
Sony Interactive Entertainment senior vice president and general counsel Stephanie Burns welcomed the decision, saying the ruling affirmed the company’s business model.
The judgment marks a significant victory for Sony amid growing scrutiny of the pricing practices of major digital marketplaces.
It follows a separate Competition Appeal Tribunal ruling against Apple last year over its App Store commissions, which it is seeking to appeal.
Click here to sign up to Retail Gazette‘s free daily email newsletter



