Debenhams chairman Sir Ian Cheshire voted off the board

Debenhams Christmas
// Sir Ian Cheshire steps down as Debenhams chairman after being voted off the board
// Sergio Bucher also voted off the board, but will remain as CEO
// Boardroom coup led by two major shareholders, one of which is Mike Ashley
// Dramatic changes occur on same day Debenhams released weak Christmas results

Debenhams has been plunged into fresh crisis after chairman Sir Ian Cheshire was forced to step down following a shareholder coup at the retailer’s AGM this afternoon.

Sergio Bucher was also voted off the Debenhams board, although he had the support of shareholders to continue on as chief executive.

The dramatic changes were prompted by a revolt from two major shareholders in the department store retailer, one of which is Mike Ashley’s Sports Direct.

The news comes on the same day Debenhams unveiled weak figures for the crucial Christmas trading period, where an overall like-for-like sales decline of 3.4 per cent was driven by a 3.6 per cent drop in UK like-for-likes.

Additionally, like-for-likes for Debenhams’ 18-week period ending January 5 was down 5.7 per cent, again underpinned by a UK decline of 6.2 per cent.

The figures were also a continuation of sustained decline in Debenhams’ fortunes in the last three years.

In 2018, it endured profit warnings and its end-of-year report in October saw the retailer swing to a massive loss before tax of £491 million – a record in the retailer’s 240-year history.

After today’s AGM, Cheshire – who first joined the Debenhams board in January 2016 and was appointed chairman the following April – informed fellow board members that due the decision of two major shareholders who voted against his re-election, he thought it was no longer possible for him to remain in the role.

He subsequently announced his resignation with immediate effect, and Debenhams’ senior independent director Terry Duddy was appointed interim chairman.

Bucher was also not re-elected to the Debenhams board principally as a result of the votes of the same two major shareholders, one of which is Ashley.

While he received 44.15 per cent of votes in favour of his re-election, excluding those two major shareholders, the vote for him to continue on the board was approximately 99.6 per cent in favour.

As a result, the board and Bucher agreed that he should continue as chief executive of Debenhams, as the board viewed it in the best interests of the retailer for him to do so.

“I recognise that individual shareholders have wished to register their dissatisfaction,” Duddy said in a statement.

“I would like to thank Ian for his strong leadership of the board and his contribution to the business. We wish him all the best for the future. I am looking forward to working with Sergio.

“My first task is to meet with shareholders so that I understand any concerns that they may have.”

Cheshire said: “It has been a great privilege to get to know my Debenhams colleagues over the past three years.

“In unprecedented market conditions the team has worked incredibly hard to build a format for the future and a comprehensive plan to reshape the business, which will put Debenhams on the road to recovery and future success.

“Whilst it is right that I step down today, I wish the team at Debenhams every success in the future.”

Cheshire’s sudden resignation also comes after he issued Ashley with an ultimatum last month in which he ordered him to make an official offer to take over Debenhams or stay out of its affairs.

Ashley – who owns a 29.7 per cent stake in Debenhams through Sports Direct – had slammed the struggling department store for rejecting his £40 million interest-free loan offer in order to save it from collapsing, in exchange for more shares in the company.

While Ashley’s offer of a loan was largely interpreted as an attempt to take over, it instead sparked a bitter and public dispute between himself and Debenhams board.

Ashley steadily increased his stake in the department store chain throughout 2018, raising it from 23 per cent to the current 29.7 per cent.

This means Sports Direct, of which Ashley is a majority owner, is only three percentage points from the threshold at which it must launch an official takeover bid.

Click here to sign up to Retail Gazette‘s free daily email newsletter


  1. God help Debenhams if Mike Ashley gets control. He’s cutting store staff at House of Fraser by 50%, has got rid of almost all head office staff and is trying to force everyone onto Sports Direct contracts. This man needs to be stopped from taking over any more high street stores

    • You do realise that HoF had been losing money for years, was trading whilst insolvent, and had proposed a CVA? And yet you think everything can go on as before? Hello?

      • Better with no job than working under him, I know I was there. He’s only interested in what he can get out of it and zero interest in the people who actually work there. How long will it last with no staff in stores? Not long, people just won’t shop there so the staff will still lose their jobs whilst he walks away making more money

  2. For how long can a CEO who has lost the confidence of shareholders and been voted off the Board of Directors remain as CEO? The only honourable course is to resign immediately. That, of course, would plunge Debenhams into even further difficulty which, in turn, may play into Ashley’s hands. I suspect this is a lose-lose situation for Debenhams.

  3. Time to bring back some good retailers that made Debenhams successful. Give John Hoerner and maybe Belinda Earll a call. Mike Ashley will only make the situation worse.

  4. Ashley will wait until it hits administration, then wait until it is packaged without outstanding debt then buy it…. leaving customers and suppliers out of pocket…. to Ashley this is just a game of strategy but unlike Monopoly this is real money, real people and real families who suffer… but to him out of sight is out of mind….


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here